AI Slop for the Holidays: Why McDonald’s and Coca-Cola’s AI Ads Fell Flat
AI Slop for the Holidays: Why McDonald’s and Coca-Cola’s AI Ads Fell Flat

AI Slop for the Holidays: Why McDonald’s and Coca-Cola’s AI Ads Fell Flat

Tessa Quinn and Carmen Alverez unpack the backlash to AI-generated holiday ads, focusing on why campaigns from McDonald’s and Coca-Cola struck many viewers as hollow instead of heartwarming. They dig into what “AI slop” actually means, what brands misread

Episode E542
December 23, 2025
06:41
Hosts: Neural Newscast
News
AI slop
advertising
media
ai analysis
artificial intelligence

Now Playing: AI Slop for the Holidays: Why McDonald’s and Coca-Cola’s AI Ads Fell Flat

Download size: 6.1 MB

Share Episode

SubscribeListen on Transistor

Episode Summary

Tessa Quinn and Carmen Alverez unpack the backlash to AI-generated holiday ads, focusing on why campaigns from McDonald’s and Coca-Cola struck many viewers as hollow instead of heartwarming. They dig into what “AI slop” actually means, what brands misread about nostalgia and craft, and how to use AI without losing trust.

Subscribe so you don't miss the next episode

Show Notes

Neural Newscast — Episode Notes

Holiday ads are supposed to feel warm, human, and weirdly specific—like they remember you. This episode looks at a recent critique making the rounds: AI holiday ads from big brands like McDonald’s and Coca-Cola that many viewers felt were… well, soulless. We talk about what went wrong, why people noticed instantly, and what better AI-assisted creative could look like.

What we cover

  • 🎄 “AI slop” explained: what people mean when they say an ad looks or feels like generated filler
  • 🍟 McDonald’s & Coca-Cola as examples: why iconic brands face extra scrutiny when they automate “magic”
  • 🧠 The uncanny holiday problem: tiny details in faces, motion, lighting, and storytelling that break the spell
  • 🧵 Nostalgia isn’t a filter: why “vibes” aren’t enough when audiences want authenticity and craft
  • 🧑‍🎨 The creative labor angle: what audiences assume about cost-cutting, jobs, and replacing artists
  • 🔍 How to do AI ads better: human direction, clear intent, real cinematography, and transparent attribution
  • 🧾 A viewer’s checklist: how to spot low-effort AI creative—and how brands can avoid it

Subscribe

If you like fast, human-friendly analysis of AI in the real world, subscribe to Neural Newscast on your favorite podcast app and share this episode with a friend.

Disclaimer: Neural Newscast is AI-assisted, human reviewed. View our AI Transparency Policy at NeuralNewscast.com.

Transcript

This transcript is sourced from the podcast feed content. It may include both show notes and transcript portions.

Neural Newscast — Episode Notes

Holiday ads are supposed to feel warm, human, and weirdly specific—like they remember you. This episode looks at a recent critique making the rounds: AI holiday ads from big brands like McDonald’s and Coca-Cola that many viewers felt were… well, soulless. We talk about what went wrong, why people noticed instantly, and what better AI-assisted creative could look like.

What we cover

  • 🎄 “AI slop” explained: what people mean when they say an ad looks or feels like generated filler
  • 🍟 McDonald’s & Coca-Cola as examples: why iconic brands face extra scrutiny when they automate “magic”
  • 🧠 The uncanny holiday problem: tiny details in faces, motion, lighting, and storytelling that break the spell
  • 🧵 Nostalgia isn’t a filter: why “vibes” aren’t enough when audiences want authenticity and craft
  • 🧑‍🎨 The creative labor angle: what audiences assume about cost-cutting, jobs, and replacing artists
  • 🔍 How to do AI ads better: human direction, clear intent, real cinematography, and transparent attribution
  • 🧾 A viewer’s checklist: how to spot low-effort AI creative—and how brands can avoid it

Subscribe

If you like fast, human-friendly analysis of AI in the real world, subscribe to Neural Newscast on your favorite podcast app and share this episode with a friend.

Disclaimer: Neural Newscast is AI-assisted, human reviewed. View our AI Transparency Policy at NeuralNewscast.com.

No separate transcript file available for this episode.